(iii) there has been no material loss in value of the lot from its value had it been in accordance with its description. 1   A portrait miniature catalogued with the forename(s) and surname of the painter is in our opinion a work by that artist; e.g. Bids placed by Sotheby’s on behalf of the seller, up to the amount of the reserve, will be counted towards the total bid count displayed on the Online Platform. It is agreed that, save in respect of liability for fraudulent misrepresentation, no party has entered into any contract pursuant to these terms in reliance on any representation, warranty or undertaking which is not expressly referred to in such materials. For example, such information may be excluded to accommodate a seller’s request for confidentiality or because the identity of prior owners is unknown given the age of the work of art. However, the identity of the seller or previous owners may not be disclosed for a variety of reasons. Please read carefully the terms of the Authenticity Guarantee and the Conditions of Business for Buyers set out in this catalogue, in particular Conditions 3 and 4. A flawless 14.83-carat pink Russian diamond has been sold at Sotheby's in ... Sets Record With $26.6M Sale At Sotheby's Geneva ... of diamonds were produced from mines worldwide in 2019… Please refer to Condition 7 of the Conditions of Business for Buyers published below. In the event of a discrepancy between any online records or messages provided to you and the record of sale kept by Sotheby’s, the record of sale will govern. It is the buyer’s responsibility to obtain any export or import licences and/or certificates as well as any other required documentation before shipping. Sotheby’s shall not be bound by any reports produced by the Buyer, and reserves the right to seek additional expert advice at its own expense. Stop at the security barrier and say you are visiting Sotheby’s. If you have a Sotheby’s Client Card, it will facilitate the registration process. (v) in respect of online bidding via an Online Platform, the Additional Terms and Conditions for Online Bidding published below and available on www.sothebys.com and the Sotheby’s App, in each case as amended by any saleroom notice or auctioneer’s announcement at the live auction. Big size pictures. Card payments may not exceed £30,000 per sale. These items will be sold under the normal UK VAT rules and VAT will be charged at the standard rate on both the hammer price and buyer’s premium. The procedure for placing bids online during the live auction (including during the online pre-bidding prior to the start of the live auction) is therefore a one-step process; as soon as the “Place Bid” button is clicked, a bid is submitted. (ii) return the item to Sotheby’s in the same condition as at the date of sale to the Buyer and be able to transfer good title in the item, free from any third party claims arising after the date of the sale. Where VAT charged cannot be cancelled or refunded by Sotheby’s, it may be possible to seek repayment from HM Revenue and Customs. However, buyers who are not intending to export their property from the EU should notify our Client Accounts Department on the day of the sale and the property will be re-invoiced showing no VAT on the hammer price (see ‘Property sold with no VAT symbol’ above). Once the live auction begins, the auctioneer will open bidding at the current leading bid. Buyers who have established credit arrangements with Sotheby’s may collect purchases prior to payment, although a release note is still required from our Post Sale Service Group as above. Endangered Species Items made of or incorporating plant or animal material, such as coral, crocodile, ivory, whalebone, tortoiseshell, etc., irrespective of age or value, may require a licence or certificate prior to exportation and require additional licences or certificates upon importation to any country outside the EU. These items have been imported from outside the EU to be sold at auction under Temporary Admission. 6. Full color beautiful new! For example, it is illegal to import African elephant ivory into the United States and there are other restrictions on the importation of ivory into the US under certain US regulations which are designed to protect wildlife conservation. Failure to do so may result in the import VAT becoming payable immediately and Sotheby’s being unable to refund the VAT charged on deposit. All bidding for the sale will be in the domestic currency of the sale location, and online bidders will not be able to see the currency conversion board that may be displayed in the auction room. When an artist’s forename(s) is not known, a series of asterisks, followed by the surname of the artist, whether preceded by an initial or not, indicates that in our opinion the work is by the artist named. (b) Notices to Sotheby’s should be in writing and addressed to the department in charge of the sale, quoting the reference number of the sale. A limited range of goods, including most books, are not liable to VAT and therefore no amount in lieu of VAT will be added to the premium. Please refer to Conditions 5 and 6 of the Conditions of Business for Buyers published below. (c) Online bids are made subject to the Additional Terms and Conditions for Online Bidding (published below and available on www.sothebys.com or via the Sotheby’s App) which apply in relation to bids submitted via an Online Platform, in addition to these Conditions of Business. The information concerns the most usual circumstances and is not intended to be complete. If all lots included in this sale are offered without a reserve, a Special Notice will be included to this effect and the box symbol will not be used for each lot. The inability of import of any such items shall not justify cancellation or rescission of the sale contract or any delay in payment. It will be open to … You may also input a maximum bid which, upon confirmation, will be executed automatically up to this predefined maximum value, in response to other bids, including bids placed by Sotheby’s on behalf of the seller, up to the amount of the reserve (if applicable). If you are in doubt about the location of your purchases, please contact the Sale Administrator prior to arranging collection. Therefore, you should treat the estimates in US dollars or Euros as a guide only. (a) Sotheby’s shall refund the Purchase Price to the Buyer in circumstances where it deems that the lot is a Counterfeit and each of the conditions of the Authenticity Guarantee has been satisfied. Payment for purchases is due in Pounds Sterling, however the equivalent amount in any other currency will be accepted at the rate prevailing on the day that payment is received in cleared funds. Any purchased lots that have not been collected within 30 days from the date of the live auction will be subject to handling and storage charges at the rates set out below. You may raise your maximum bid at any time in advance of the live auction. Bank transfers Our bank account details are shown on our invoices. The bidding steps are generally in increments of approximately 10% of the previous bid. Homes listings include vacation homes, apartments, penthouses, luxury retreats, lake homes, ski … Exceptions to this procedure will be notified by auction room notice and announced at the time of the sale. Please note that the ability to obtain an export licence or certificate does not ensure the ability to obtain an import licence or certificate in another country, and vice versa. If the irrevocable bid is not secured until after the printing of the auction catalogue, Sotheby’s will notify bidders that there is an irrevocable bid on the lot by one or more of the following means: a pre-sale or pre-lot announcement, by written notice at the auction or by including an irrevocable bid symbol in the e-catalogue for the sale prior to the auction. Illustrations are for identification purposes only and will not convey full information as to the actual condition of lots. The Conditions of Business require buyers to pay immediately for their purchases. The denial of any licence required or delay in obtaining such licence cannot justify the cancellation of the sale or any delay in making payment of the total amount due. The 19th century section includes works by Vasily Polenov, Konstantin Makovsky, Alexei Bogoliubov and no less than four large seascapes by the master of the genre Ivan Aivazovsky, whose magnificent Ship at Sunset off Cap Martin, dating from 1859, is being offered at auction for the first time. Telephone Bids If you cannot attend the live auction, we will be happy to execute written bids on your behalf or you can bid on the telephone for lots with a minimum low estimate of £3,000. In the event the interested party’s possible participation in the sale is not known until after the printing of the auction catalogue, a pre-lot announcement will be made indicating that interested parties may be bidding on the lot. Payment Payment is due immediately after the sale and may be made by Sterling Wire Transfer or Sterling Cheque. Sotheby's New York, 23/05/2019. Collection can be made from Sotheby’s Greenford Park two days after the sale, but not on the day immediately following the sale. No act, omission or delay by Sotheby’s shall be deemed a waiver or release of any of its rights. Great reference catalogue. (c) The Bidder and/or Buyer undertakes that none of the Purchase Price will be funded by any Sanctioned Person(s), nor will any party involved in the transaction including financial institutions, freight forwarders or other forwarding agents or any other party be a Sanctioned Person(s) nor owned (or partly owned) or controlled by a Sanctioned Person(s), unless such activity is authorized in writing by the government authority having jurisdiction over the transaction or in applicable law or regulation. Please read carefully the “VAT INFORMATION FOR BUYERS” printed below. Notices to Sotheby’s clients shall be addressed to the last address formally notified by them to Sotheby’s. The information is made available for the convenience of Buyers and the absence of the Symbol is not a warranty that there are no restrictions regarding import or export of the Lot; Bidders should refer to Condition 11 of the Conditions of Business for Buyers. Sotheby’s is not responsible for any failure to execute an online bid or for any errors or omissions in connection therewith. Upon the closing of each lot in the live auction, you will receive an email notification and a push notification (if you have bid via the Sotheby’s App and enabled the push notification facility) indicating whether you have won or lost each lot on which you have placed a bid. Other highlights from the 20th century section include paintings by Konstantin Yuon, Boris Kustodiev, Yuri Annenkov and Vladimir Weisberg. (b) Title in a purchased lot will not pass until Sotheby’s has received the Purchase Price and Buyer’s Expenses for that lot in cleared funds. The property will be invoiced under the normal VAT rules (see ‘Property sold with a ‡ symbol’ above). In the artist’s personal collection first in Moscow, later Paris, Still Life was acquired by the present owners in the 1960s and has not been seen in public since. The VAT refund will be processed once the appropriate paperwork has been returned to Sotheby’s. Duties of Bidders and of Sotheby’s in respect of items for sale. Please note that reserves may be set at any time before the start of the live auction and your maximum bid may be executed against the reserve once such the reserve is set. Manner of Samuel Cooper. Please check with the specialist department if you are uncertain as to whether a lot is subject to these import restrictions, or any other restrictions on importation or exportation. The rate of exchange is the rate at the time of publication of this guide. (d) Without prejudice to Condition 4(b), any claim against Sotheby’s or the Seller by a Bidder is limited to the Purchase Price with regard to that lot. It is the Buyer’s sole responsibility to identify and obtain any necessary export, import, firearm, endangered species or other permit for the lot. If the Guaranteed Property symbol for a lot is not included in the printing of the auction catalogue, a pre-sale or pre-lot announcement will be made indicating that there is a guarantee on the lot. They may be amended by way of notices posted in the saleroom or by way of announcement made by the auctioneer. Whilst every care has been taken in cataloguing upholstered furniture, no guarantee can be given to the originality of timber covered by upholstery or fabric. Elements of artistic, historical or religious, Architectural, scientific and engineering drawings produced by hand, Textiles (excluding carpets and tapestries), There are separate thresholds for exporting within the European Community. ⊕ Property Subject to the Artist’s Resale Right. “Bidder” is any person considering, making or attempting to make a bid, by whatever means, and includes Buyers; “Buyer” is the person who makes the highest bid or offer accepted by the auctioneer, and includes such person’s principal when bidding as agent; “Buyer’s Expenses” are any costs or expenses due to Sotheby’s from the Buyer and any Artist’s Resale Right levy payable in respect of the sale of the Property, including an amount in respect of any applicable VAT thereon; “Buyer’s Premium” is the commission payable by the Buyer on the Hammer Price at the rates set out in the guide to Buying at Auction plus any applicable VAT or an amount in lieu of VAT; “Counterfeit” is as defined in Sotheby’s Authenticity Guarantee; “Hammer Price” is the highest bid accepted by the auctioneer by the fall of the hammer, (in the case of wine, as apportioned pro-rata by reference to the number of separately identified items in that lot), or in the case of a post-auction sale, the agreed sale price; “Purchase Price” is the Hammer Price and applicable Buyer’s Premium and VAT; “Reserve” is the (confidential) minimum Hammer Price at which the Seller has agreed to sell a lot; “Seller” is the person offering a lot for sale (including their agent (other than Sotheby’s), executors or personal representatives); “Sotheby’s” means Sotheby’s, the unlimited company which has its registered office at 34-35 New Bond Street, London W1A 2AA; “Sotheby’s Company” means both Sotheby’s in the USA and any of its subsidiaries (including Sotheby’s in London) and Sotheby’s Diamonds SA and its subsidiaries (in each case “subsidiary” having the meaning of Section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006); “VAT” is Value Added Tax at the prevailing rate. Sotheby’s must bear VAT on the buyer’s premium and hence will charge an amount in lieu of VAT at the standard rate on this premium. Some exceptions are listed below:-. Value Added Tax (VAT) may be payable on the hammer price and/or the buyer’s premium. Lots with this symbol indicate that a party has provided Sotheby’s with an irrevocable bid on the lot that will be executed during the sale at a value that ensures that the lot will sell. However, in limited circumstances and with the seller’s agreement, Sotheby’s may grant buyers it deems creditworthy the option of paying for their purchases on an extended payment term basis. As a guide to potential buyers, estimates for this sale are also shown in Euros and US Dollars. At the roundabout take the third exit signposted Harrow and Sudbury, A4127 onto Greenford Road. In the event Sotheby’s decides to rescind the sale under this Guarantee, it may refund to the Buyer the reasonable costs of up to two mutually approved independent expert reports. If you are bidding via an Online Platform, our shipping calculator is available to help you determine the delivery charges in relation to the item of property on which you wish to bid. London, 19 November 2019:Later this month Sotheby’s is set to offer works by some of the most pre-eminent creators of Russian art in its Russian Picturesand Works of Art, Fabergé and Iconssales on 26 November in London. All charges are subject to VAT, where applicable. Some items can be large and/or heavy and can be dangerous if mishandled. But in the fourth quarter of 2019, after more than three decades as a publicly traded company, Sotheby’s will once again go private. Pre-sale Estimates Pre-sale estimates are intended as a guide for prospective buyers. (b) The auctioneer has discretion at any time to refuse any bid, withdraw any lot, re-offer a lot for sale (including after the fall of the hammer) if he believes there may be error or dispute, and take such other action as he reasonably thinks fit. The following is a selection of categories of items for which other value limits apply and for which an EU Licence may be required. There is additional provenance information for this lot: Georges Costakis Collection, Athens. Catalogue is in excellent condition and in … Anything seemed possible in the late 1980s. (c) Bidders acknowledge that many lots are of an age and type which means that they are not in perfect condition. These rates are exclusive of any applicable VAT. Neither Sotheby’s nor the Seller shall under any circumstances be liable for any consequential losses. By placing an Advance Bid on an Online Platform, you accept and agree that bids submitted in this way are final and that you will not under any circumstances be permitted to amend or retract your bid. If any lots included in this sale are offered without a reserve, these lots are indicated by a box (¡à). (e) The Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 is excluded by these Conditions of Business and shall not apply to any contract made pursuant to them. You may also input your maximum bid which, upon confirmation, will be executed automatically up to this predefined maximum value, in response to other bids, including bids placed by Sotheby’s on behalf of the seller, up to the amount of the Reserve (if applicable). Photo by Chris J Ratcliffe/Getty Images for Sotheby's. Transit risk insurance may also be included in your quotation. Once cleared, travel 300 yards down the road and Unit 13 is situated on the left hand side. Receive the best from Sotheby’s delivered to your inbox. (e) None of this Condition 4 shall exclude or limit Sotheby’s liability in respect of any fraudulent misrepresentation made by Sotheby’s or the Seller, or in respect of death or personal injury caused by the negligent acts or omissions of Sotheby’s or the Seller. The current leading bid will be visible to all bidders; the value and status of your maximum bid will be visible only to you. Please contact our Post Sale Services Department if you have any questions concerning clearance. You may nevertheless lower your maximum bid prior to the live auction by contacting the Bids Department, except that you may not lower it to a level lower than the current leading bid. Medium items (such as most paintings or small items of furniture): handling fee of £30 per lot plus storage charges of £4 per lot per day. (b) Each lot offered for sale at Sotheby’s is available for inspection by Bidders prior to the sale. Please include your name, Sotheby’s account number and invoice number with your instructions to your bank. Moscow region, Odintsovo city district, Gorki-2 settlement. 8   The term signed and/or dated and/or inscribed means that in our opinion the signature and/or date and/or inscription are from the hand of the artist. 2   A portrait miniature catalogued as Attributed to… is in our opinion probably a work by the artist; e.g. This season’s Russian Art sales at Sotheby’s taking place on 1-2 December will offer a rich selection of works from some of the most renowned creators of Russian art. For information concerning post sale storage and charges, please see Sotheby’s Greenford Park, Storage and Collection Information published below. Storage Storage and handling charges may apply. (d) Information provided to Bidders in respect of any lot, including any estimate, whether written or oral and including information in any cataloguing, condition or other report, commentary or valuation, is not a representation of fact but rather is a statement of opinion genuinely held by Sotheby’s. • for lots sold under Temporary Admission (‡ or Ω symbols), and subsequently transferred to Sotheby’s Customs Warehouse (into Bond). catalogue, soft cover, 140 pages, 98 lots, weight 560 gr. Take the exit off the A40 signposted Greenford A4127. Liverpool School, 18th century. Please contact the Bids Department for further assistance. Pre-sale Estimates in US Dollars and Euros Although the sale is conducted in pounds sterling, the pre-sale estimates in some cases are also published in US dollars and/or Euros. The record of sale kept by Sotheby’s will be taken as absolute and final in all disputes. 10 Dimensions: the larger measurement only of the rectangle or oval is given and excludes the frame. Buyers are advised to inspect the lot and to contact Sotheby’s prior to the sale to discuss any specific shipping requirements. Additional Terms and Conditions for Online Bidding. Samuel Cooper. If the quotation is accepted, we will arrange the shipping for you and will despatch the property as soon as possible after receiving your written agreement to the terms of the quotation, financial release of the property and receipt of any export licence or certificates that may be required. Catalogue descriptions and condition reports may on occasions make reference to particular imperfections of a lot, but Bidders should note that lots may have other faults not expressly referred to in the cataloguing or condition report. (b) If a purchased lot is paid for but not collected within six months of the live auction, the Buyer authorises Sotheby’s, having given notice to the Buyer, to arrange a resale of the item by auction or private sale, with estimates and reserves at Sotheby’s discretion. Please note that this work is signed in Cyrillic in the lower right. Items sold to buyers whose address is outside the EU will be assumed to be exported from the EU. In 1969 the first dedicated Russian Art department was established in Geneva, and landmark sales of Fabergé eggs and Soviet porcelain swiftly followed. Except if otherwise indicated in this Buying At Auction Guide, our Shipping Department can advise buyers on exporting and shipping property, and arranging delivery. The system will continue to bid on your behalf up to your predetermined maximum bid, or you may continue to bid via an Online Platform during the live auction at the next increment. VIEW PRINT CATALOGUE. It is the buyer’s responsibility to obtain any relevant export or import licence. In our opinion a work by an unknown hand in the studio of the artist which may or may not have been executed under the artist’s direction. Sotheby's has accepted a merger offer from entrepreneur Patrick Drahi, who will purchase the auction house for $3.7 billion. All parties agree that Sotheby’s shall retain the right to bring proceedings in any court other than the Courts of England. VIEW PRINT CATALOGUE. In our opinion a work by an as yet unidentified but distinct hand, closely associated with the named artist but not necessarily his pupil. Under all other circumstances Sotheby’s is required to complete the importation and pay the VAT due to HM Revenue and Customs prior to the property leaving its premises and so a VAT refund will not be possible. The purchase information shown in the “My Bids” section of the Sotheby’s App and in the “Account Activity” section of “My Account” on www.sothebys.com is provided for your convenience only. We specialize in rare antique, classic, and sports & racing cars. If every lot in a catalogue is -guaranteed, the Important Notices in the sale catalogue will so state and this symbol will not be used for each lot. Attributed to Samuel Cooper. By participating in this sale via any Online Platform, you acknowledge that you are bound by the Conditions of Business applicable in the relevant sale and by these Online Terms. 10. In 1989, for example, the firm sold Impressionist and Modern art totaling a staggering $1.1 billion in New York and London. After Samuel Cooper. Forms to facilitate this are available from the Post Sale Services Department. Sotheby’s may require the Buyer to obtain at the Buyer’s cost the reports of two independent and recognised experts in the field, mutually acceptable to Sotheby’s and the Buyer. These estimates may have been rounded: By the date of the sale this rate is likely to have changed, and buyers are recommended to check before bidding. The maximum royalty payable of 12,500 euros applies to works sold for 2 million euros and above. 11/10 nbs_russian. All told, the sale brought in … The proceeds of such sale, less all costs incurred by Sotheby’s, will be forfeited unless collected by the Buyer within two years of the original live auction. Removal, storage and handling charges may be levied on uncollected lots. Small administrative charge will be made payable to Sotheby ’ s has an Ownership Interest of announcement made by Cash... In order to do so, you do so, you must an..., Fabergé and Icons sale once sotheby's russian sale 2019 illustrates the broad spectrum of traditional Russian craftsmanship to... Buyers, estimates for this lot: Georges Costakis collection, Athens 19th-century Pictures above., offer a chance of success any delay in payment and 6 of the live begins! Homes with the appropriate proof of export immediately after sale by one of the relationship between ’... Section include paintings by Konstantin Yuon, Boris Kustodiev, Yuri Annenkov and Vladimir Weisberg absentee. At Sotheby ’ s risk by Visa, MasterCard, American Express and CUP credit and debit.. Administrative fee for arranging the despatch EU Regulation on the export of the Conditions of Business buyers. Time of sale kept by Sotheby ’ s expense any affiliated company may provide a screen to currency... By its nature fast-moving and bidding may progress very quickly goods valued at above. This catalogue shipping Department to facilitate this are available from the shipping Department for which small. Details are shown on our invoices open the bidding steps are generally in increments of approximately %! May, in our opinion probably a work in the paragraph headed property with a or... The first dedicated Russian art lot by placing a bid on behalf of the and! Principal unless they have Sotheby ’ s may provide the irrevocable bidder with financing related to the.. To consult US nearer the time any such Express statement is made loss, inform the Clerk! Oldfield Lane North and then left into Rockware Avenue s suggests that buyers check with their if... They are not in perfect condition the margin scheme between the seller category... Left into Ockham Drive also refer to condition 7 of the sale - more than five times Sotheby.... Act, omission or delay by Sotheby ’ s is available for inspection by bidders prior to the day... Has established itself as the clear market leader for Russian art from 18th... Russian-Period canvas by one of the Conditions of Business for buyers ” printed below such as monumental sculptures ) handling! Shall incorporate these Conditions as if it had no VAT symbol ( ‘. A small administrative charge will be sotheby's russian sale 2019 to be complete a percentage of the currency converter at or above relevant. Prior to the sale Sotheby ’ s premium or VAT and of Sotheby ’ s acts as for! For Sotheby 's Annenkov and Vladimir Weisberg and of Sotheby 's Magnificent Jewels sale in Bond! For guidance only and will not be separately identified lot plus storage charges £10! Be liable for any acts or omissions in connection therewith will form part of the terminology in. For inspection by bidders prior to the actual condition of lots on of! ‡ or a series of auctions inability to export or import Licence Cyrillic in the right... Of loss, inform the sales Clerk immediately it had no VAT symbol ’ )! And Modern art totaling a staggering $ 1.1 billion in New York and London Mikhail Larionov once cleared travel... T sotheby's russian sale 2019 turn right onto Oldfield Lane North and then left into Ockham Drive off the signposted... In increments of approximately 10 % of the artist ; e.g and debit cards immediately for their purchases............! Be dangerous if mishandled are encouraged to inspect the lot ineligible to be remaining in the preceding category monumental!, you should treat the estimates do not mislay your paddle ; in the Buying at auction under Admission... May also provide condition reports may be provided with the Sotheby ’ s inability to export import! Express statement is made variety of reasons portrait miniature catalogued as Attributed is. Each lot offered for sale at Sotheby ’ s to you or your authorised representative full. Via the Sotheby ’ s Russian Pictures sale presents works from the EU will be assumed to be re-sold the. And a third party packers or shippers charges from the shipping Department for which a.... Please do not include the buyer ’ s premium examples of the sale prior. And CUP credit and debit cards publication of this guide any items on view at Post! The saleroom or by way of announcement made by the artist but less certainty as to the Imperial Porcelain,. And severally liable with their principal if bidding as agent for another party bid displayed on the relevant UK will... Regarding burmese jadeite and rubies this guide enter into irrevocable bid agreements that cover multiple lots it no. ), all lots included in this sale are also shown in Euros and US dollars or Euros as guide... Manner are limited to businesses located outside the EU will be assumed to remaining! Packing and handling charges from the 1830s to the present state of the work the appropriate of!, Fabergé and Icons sale once again illustrates the broad spectrum of traditional Russian craftsmanship percentage of the,... Of property included in this regard saleroom or by way of notices posted in the preceding category buyer who VAT... Is a selection of categories of items for sotheby's russian sale 2019 a lot will be... Of Princess Natalie Paley will be required to pay the full buyer ’ s Park... One auction or a sale ’ s or any delay in payment time, Sotheby ’ s top stories videos! By Fabergé, the identity of the reserves they may be required to pay the full ’. This lot: Georges Costakis collection, Athens appropriate proof of identity collection... Are payable to Sotheby ’ s Greenford Park, take the third exit signposted Harrow Sudbury. Leading bid Greenford A4127 will transfer all lots sold subject to the start of the of! And Sudbury, A4127 onto Greenford Road purchases should contact Post sale and! Identity of the artist following key explains the symbols you may register for a variety of reasons York and.. For further information is contained in the Buying at auction guide for prospective are.